Sunday, November 3, 2024

Race Report: 2024 City of Oaks Marathon

On November 3, I ran the City of Oaks Marathon in Raleigh, NC.  This race has easy logistics.  If you stay in a downtown hotel, you can walk to the start and walk back from the finish.

When I ran this same race two years ago, it took me more than four and a half hours to finish.  There were several reasons for that.  First, I had a cold.  Second, I wasn’t in peak shape.  Even on a good day, I wasn’t fast enough to break four hours.  Finally, it was a warm day, and I was feeling the humidity from the first mile.

This year I had every reason to expect to be faster.  I’m healthy, I’m in better shape, and the weather was cooler.

I ran Boston qualifying times in my last four races, but they were all on courses that were mostly flat.  This race has lots of hills.  Running a qualifying time on this course would be more challenging.

I flew to Raleigh on Saturday.  On my way into town, I stopped at the LeRoy Martin Magnet Middle School to pick up my race packet.  Each year, there’s some type of gift at the expo.  This year, it was a pair of socks.

After packet pickup, I continued to my hotel in downtown Raleigh.  Then I spent most of the afternoon walking around the downtown area.  I’ve been to Raleigh twice before, so I wanted to do some different sightseeing.  This time, I followed a walking route I found online that connects several buildings that have murals.

This mural is called “All Are Welcome.”  It was hard to get an unobstructed view of this one, because there was a car parked right in front of it.  As a bonus, I saw another mural on the same building.


This mural, outside Shaw University, celebrates their 150th anniversary.

This one depicts Ann and Allen Iverson.

This mural is called “No Damsel.”  This isn't the whole thing, but I couldn't get it all in one picture.

This mural on the side of the Lincoln Theater is called “Honest Abe.”

This one is called “Abstraction Motion.”  It incorporates Google Fiber, so you can both see and feel it.

This mural of John Prine was painted during the 2018 World of Bluegrass International Festival.

This mural is called “Color Pop Corner.”

There’s artwork on the back of the convention center that’s lit up at night, but it’s nothing special during the day, so I didn’t take a picture.  I did, however, take a picture of the statue next to the front of the building.

There was one mural on the tour that was missing.  It used to be on a building that’s now part of a reconstruction project.  While I never got to see that one, I saw several other murals that weren’t part of the tour.  I also saw other forms of artwork.

I didn’t have any lunch, so I had an early dinner.  I went to Raleigh Beer Garden, which was just around the block from my hotel.  Their menu includes pizza, and they have more than 300 beers on tap.

This was the weekend that we set the clocks back.  Before going to bed, I checked to make sure the alarm clock in my room was set up to change automatically.  I also manually changed the clock on the microwave, so I wouldn’t be confused if I happened to notice it when I got up during the night.

When I got up on Sunday, the temperature was in the upper 40s, but it looked like it might get up to 50 by the time the race started.  That’s my usual threshold for wearing shorts.

In my last four races, I wore tights, and at times I felt too warm.  This time, I was going to wear shorts.  Thirty minutes before the race, I checked the weather.  It was still only 46 degrees, so I made a last-minute decision to wear tights.  It was the usual trade-off between being cold in the first half of the race or possibly getting hot in the second half.

They had a gear check, but I didn’t need to use it.  The starting line was just a few blocks from my hotel, so I didn’t go outside until 20 minutes before the race.

I didn’t know if there would be pace groups until I reached the start corrals.  They had pace groups, but their target times were all multiples of 15 minutes.  My goal was 3:50, and I expected that to be challenging on this course.  On a flat course, I might have started with the 3:45 group.  Instead, I lined up about 10 feet behind them and started at my own pace.

When I was walking around downtown Raleigh on Saturday, I couldn’t help but notice that every block was either uphill or downhill.  None of the hills was steep, but there weren’t any streets that were flat.  That made it difficult to know how fast I was starting.

The first few blocks were slightly uphill.  It seemed like I was starting at a slower pace than I usually do, but I was breathing harder than usual.

After a few blocks, we turned a corner and started running downhill.  Suddenly, running was easier.  I sped up, but I wasn’t working as hard.

During those first few blocks, the 3:45 pace group got so far ahead of me that I lost sight of them.  By the end of the first mile, I could see them again.  They were about half a block ahead of me.

To finish in 3:50, I needed to average 8:46 per mile.  I was surprised to see that I ran the first mile in 8:10.  The 3:45 group was evidently starting kind of fast.  Their target pace was 8:35, but they started even faster than I did.

The second mile was mostly downhill.  I still found it hard to gauge how fast I was running, because I couldn’t really go by perceived exertion.  Instead, I just kept up with the people around me, even though I had reason to believe it would be too fast.  My second mile was a little faster than my first mile.  As a result, I was now getting closer to the 3:45 group.

Early in the third mile, we turned a corner and started going up a hill.  I was careful not to work too hard on the hill.  I gradually dropped back from the 3:45 group.  Then I reached an aid station, and I briefly slowed to a walk while I drank some Gatorade.  That caused me to fall farther behind the 3:45 group.

The more I drifted back from the 3:45 group, the more it felt reasonable to keep up with the people around me.  That gave me more confidence that I would stay on a consistent pace.

There were lots of turns in the early miles.  Depending on which direction I was running, I sometimes felt a cold breeze.  It wasn’t windy enough to feel tiring, but it made me glad that I wore tights.  For the time being, I wasn’t in any danger of getting hot, but without the tights, I probably would’ve been cold.

After a couple fast miles, it seemed like the 3:45 group settled into the right pace.  I was running pretty close to their target pace, and I was always about a block behind them.  Then we reached a long downhill section, and I inadvertently caught up to them.

It was a large pace group, and they were spread out across the road.  I was running right behind them, but I was careful not to let myself get ahead of them.

The next time we reached an uphill section, I gradually drifted back from the 3:45 group.  Then we reached a downhill section that was steeper, and I accidentally got ahead of the group.  I eased up as much as I could without actually resisting the hill, but I was still in front of the group.  When the road turned uphill again, I fell behind them for good.  For most of the race, I could see them in the distance, but I never caught up to them again.

Around seven miles, we turned a corner and merged in with runners who were doing the 10K race.  I’m not sure how many miles those runners had run by now, but their pace was definitely slower.  There were lines of slow runners that I needed to pass.

I could no longer be confident that I could stay on pace just by keeping up with the runners behind me.  I had to pay attention to keeping up with the faster runners, while moving around the slower ones.  We were going up a hill at this point, so I had to pick up my effort to keep up with the faster runners.  Going up that hill, I got warm enough that I finally took off my gloves.

At the top of the hill, the 10K runners had a turnaround.  Those of us doing the marathon or half marathon kept going straight.  Now, I was once again surrounded by runners who were all going at the same pace.

I was relieved to be done with that hill.  I was also relieved that there were no longer any slower runners on the course.  At the same time, I also knew that I was nearing the end of the easy part of the course.  In another mile, we would leave the streets to begin a long out-and-back section on the Reedy Creek Trail, which is a paved bike path.  On roads, there were hills, but they were all fairly gradual.  The hills on the trail are sometimes steeper, and the abrupt changes in slope make it harder to stay in a consistent rhythm.  So far, I was running faster than my goal pace, but I expected that to be more difficult on the trail.

I wasn’t running with a pace group, but I wanted to be able to compare my pace to other runners.  Before we reached the trail, I was hoping to pick out one or two runners who seemed like they were running a consistent pace.  My plan was to follow them through the various undulations along the trail.

There had been different runners around me at different times, but as I looked around, I spotted one runner who always seemed to be about 20 feet in front of me.  It was a woman in a pink top and white shorts.  I didn’t know, however, if she was doing the marathon or the half marathon.  I wouldn’t have to wait much longer to find out.

Shortly after the eight mile mark, we reached the point were the marathon and half marathon routes diverged.  The woman in the pink top was doing the half marathon.  Those of us doing the marathon left the roads and entered the Reedy Creek Trail.

I took note of which runners were immediately in front of me.  One was a guy wearing a red shirt and a camelback.  Another was wearing a blue shirt and a white hat.  I kept up with these two guys over the next few ups and downs.  Then I inadvertently got ahead of them.  What’s surprising is that I passed them going up a hill.  When we reached a long downhill section, I sped away from them.

I remembered how much the hills on this trail took me out of my rhythm when I ran this race two years ago.  I didn’t remember that there was a downhill trend on the way out.

Over the next two miles, it seemed like we were mostly running downhill.  That scared me, because I would eventually have to run it in the uphill direction.

Mile 10 was mostly downhill, and I ran it in 7:56.  That was my fastest mile of the race.  I was back to being only about 30 seconds behind the 3:45 group.

Mile 11 was also mostly downhill.  That was my second fastest mile of the race.  I was getting closer to the 3:45 group, although it would take an effort to catch up to them.

I wasn’t trying to catch up to the group, but I wanted to keep them within sight.  Behind the group, there was a big gap.  My choices were to either stay close to the group or resign myself to running completely by myself.  As long as I could see the group, I could tell if I was maintaining a similar pace.

At one point, we went under a bridge, turned a sharp corner, and them climbed a ramp up to street level.  Then we crossed the same bridge that we had just gone under.

Going under the bridge, I was as close as I would get to the 3:45 group.  Going up the ramp, I was careful to conserve energy.  I slowed down, and as a result, I fell farther behind the group.

After crossing the bridge, we turned back onto the trail and went deep into the forest again.

Most of the time that we were on the Reedy Creek Trail, we were surrounded by trees.  We were sheltered from the sun, but not from the wind.  There was a constant breeze, and it felt surprisingly cold.  With each mile, my hands felt colder, until they felt like ice.  I told myself to enjoy it while it lasted.  I still expected to get hot later in the race.

For a long time, I was running by myself, but then I was passed by a runner wearing an orange shirt.  I wanted to run with him, but his pace seemed too fast.  It occurred to me that he was going to catch up to the 3:45 group.  If I could keep up with him, he would pull me up to the group.

I stayed with him for a while, but then we reached a steep hill.  The hill was short, but it forced me to slow down.  That was as close as I would get to catching up with the 3:45 group.

That hill took us up to a street, and for the next several blocks, we were running on a concrete sidewalk.  I was worried about tripping on an uneven seam between two sections of sidewalk, so I ran more cautiously here.  That caused me to slow down.

The halfway point was on this concrete section.  When I got there, I was on pace for 3:42.  I was three minutes ahead of my goal pace.  The 3:45 group got there at least 30 seconds ahead of me, so they were still going fast.

I knew that I would have more uphill running in the second half of the race, so I expected to slow down.  I was optimistic that I could run a Boston qualifying time, but I definitely wasn’t going to try for negative splits.

The section on concrete sidewalk was initially uphill, but them it turned downhill.  Even going downhill, I had to take it at a cautious pace.  At the end of that section, we reached an aid station.  Then we crossed the street and backtracked a short distance to where we could get back onto the trail.

As I grabbed a cup of Gatorade at the aid station, a drop of Gatorade flew into my left eye.  I had forgotten how much that stings.  I briefly had difficulty keeping that eye open.

Now that I was back on the trail, I was able to pick up my pace.  It was getting more tiring though.  I usually find it easier to push myself when I’m in the second half of a race.  This race was an exception.  I was still almost three miles from the turnaround.  As long as I was still heading out, I didn’t feel like I was in the second half of the race.  For now, I could only think about how far it still was to the turnaround.

By now, I was starting to see faster runners who were already on their way back.  Now that we had two-way traffic on the trail, we had to keep to the right to make room for the runners who were going the other direction.  We could no longer run the tangents going around the turns.

I started to encounter more and more things that took me out of my rhythm.  Sometimes it was a hill.  Sometimes it was a sharp turn.  Sometimes it was a wooden bridge.  At one point, it was all three at once.  We were on a wooden pedestrian bridge that went underneath a larger bridge.  There were sharp turns and some rapid ups and downs as we went under the bridge.  I slowed down so much here that five runners passed me in rapid succession.

After that, we went up the steepest hill in the race.  I wondered if I would need to walk it.  When I saw the runners ahead of me walking it, I followed suit.

At the top of the hill, we came to a clearing.  This was one of the few places along the Reedy Creek Trail where spectators could easy watch the race.  I recognized this as the spot where some friends were watching for me two years ago.

Next, we ran past a small lake.  Then we went deep into the forest again.

I was now within a mile of the turnaround.  As I got closer, I saw a pace group coming back from the turnaround.  I was surprised to see it was the 3:45 group.  I thought I was still half a mile from the turnaround, but it was actually just ahead of me.

Coming back from the turn, I started to run with more confidence.  I spotted the runner with the red short and the camelback.  I had passed him several miles earlier.  Then he passed me in one of my slower miles.  Now I was on the verge of catching him again.  He was going faster than most of the other runners around us, so I followed him.

Although I wasn’t keeping up with the 3:45 group, I was usually running a similar pace.  In miles 14 through 16, my average pace was 8:46, but before that, my pace was usually in the 8:30s.  It’s worth noting that 8:46 was my goal pace.  Those miles felt slow, but only by comparison with all the faster miles.

In mile 17, I sped up to 8:32, while chasing the guy in the red shirt.  He was setting a good pace for me.

Toward the end of that mile, I ran down the same steep hill where I had to walk going uphill.  It was so steep that running it in the downhill direction was uncomfortable.  I felt one of my insoles slip forward in my shoe.

Right after that, we reached the wooden bridge with hills and turns.  I took it faster in this direction, but I tripped on something just before the bridge.  I didn’t fall, but it scared me.  After that, I accelerated, and I passed the guy in the red shirt.  Mile 18 was another 8:32 mile.

I was pleased with my pace in those two miles, but I still had five more miles on the trail, and they were going to have an uphill trend.  In the next mile, I reached a hill that was long enough that I had to walk the steepest part of it.  That mile was slower.

I was discouraged at first to have slowed to 8:58 in mile 19.  That was my slowest mile so far.  Then it occurred to me that it was only 12 seconds slower than my goal pace.  I wasn’t keeping track, but I knew had to be at least three and a half minutes ahead of schedule going into that mile.  I could easily afford to give back 12 seconds.

In mile 20, I picked up the pace again.  I gained back seven seconds of the 12 that I had lost in the previous mile.  I knew the next three miles would be slow, but I had a large cushion.  I was confident that I could maintain a steady pace when I got back onto city streets.  My concern was losing time on the hills in the last three miles of the trail.

Mile 21 had another hill that forced me to walk.  I was disciplined and only walked for 30 seconds.  I gave back 37 seconds in that mile.  Mile 22 also had a hill that forced me to do some walking.  In that mile, I gave back 19 seconds.

I was giving back time, but I was limiting the damage.  I estimated that I still had a cushion of at least two and a half minutes.

Mile 23 was the toughest.  There was a hill that was so long that I couldn’t see the whole thing at once.  I walked the steepest part of the hill.  Then I resumed running to what I thought was the top of the hill.  I turned a corner and saw that I wasn’t even halfway to the top.  I had to take another walking break.

That wasn’t the last hill in that mile, but it was the last one that forced me to walk.  When I crested the hill, I accelerated.  I started passing most of the other runners, but there was one runner who kept up with me going downhill.  She passed me, but I kept pace with her.

At the end of that mile, I was running strong, but overall, that mile was slow.  It was by far my slowest mile of the race.  In just one mile, I gave back more than a minute of my cushion.

I was thinking we would leave the trail before the 23 mile mark, but I was wrong.  We still had about half a mile on the trail.  Fortunately, this section was mostly downhill.  Then we finally came out onto the streets again.

I knew the rest of the race would have a downhill trend, but the first few blocks were slightly uphill.  I fought my way uphill without losing much time.  When I finished mile 24, I saw that I had gained back more than 20 seconds.

I had been trying to keep up with the woman who passed me in mile 23, but she was too fast.  Then she stopped briefly at an aid station.  I passed her at the aid station and accelerated as I began a long downhill section.  I ran that section as fast as I could, but she was a strong closer.  She eventually passed me gain, and I couldn’t keep up with her, even though I sped up to 8:10 in that mile.

Coming back into the downtown area, we had a strong headwind.  Up until now, the wind was always my friend.  It kept me from getting hot.  Now, the wind was tiring.

With 1.2 miles to go, I knew I would break 3:50 by a comfortable margin, but I could see another hill ahead of me.

Another fast runner passed me.  I wanted to try to keep up with him, but I had to conserve energy for the hill.

That was the last hill of any significance.  After the hill, it was almost all downhill to the finish.  At first, I wasn’t recognizing any of the buildings or street names.  Then I ran past a fast food restaurant that I had walked by on Saturday.  I had a better feel for where I was.

As I approached what I thought was the final turn, I saw a runner who had already finished and was walking back to his hotel.  He said, “Get around the corner, and it’s downhill to the finish.”

I rounded the corner, but I still couldn’t see the finish.  On the plus side, it was noticeably downhill.

I raced down the hill, and I reached the “26” sign.  I ran that mile in 8:12.  I was crushing it, but I still couldn’t see the finish line.  There were still two more turns.

I made the first of those turns, and I immediately saw the second one.  It was just one short block.  It was slightly uphill, but my momentum carried me to the last turn.  Then I could see the finish line, and the final approach was downhill.

This was my first race using a watch that I’ve only had for 10 days.  It’s similar to my old watch, but saving the data from a run is more complicated.  There are two extra steps.  I have to rate how hard I ran and how I felt.  I was so preoccupied with saving my data, that I never looked at my time.  I knew I beat my goal by at least a few minutes, but I walked away from the finish line not knowing my time.

I love the design of the finisher medal.  It features a large acorn that spins.  There are also acorns and oak leaves on the ribbon.

There were volunteers handing one water bottles, but I didn’t take one.  My hotel was less than two blocks away, and I had plenty of water there.  I did, however, make a point of getting some post-race food.

A volunteer at the food tent handed me a banana and a bag with other snacks.  At another table, they had cookies and skewers with cold cuts.  I took a cookie, but I passed on the cold cuts.

When I got back to my hotel room, there were several things I wanted to do first.  I wanted to download the data from my watch.  I wanted to look up my official result.  I wanted to eat my snacks.  I wanted to use the bathroom.  I wanted to get out of my sweaty clothes and take a bath.  More important than all of those was getting out of my sweaty shoes and socks.  I could not do that fast enough.

Shortly after downloading the data from my watch, I noticed I had an email with my official result.  I finished in 3:45:50, which was good for third place in my age group.  I qualified for Boston by more than four minutes, and I did it on a hilly course.  I had BQs in my previous four races, but those were all on relatively flat courses.

I never regretted wearing tights.  Later in the race, it was getting warmer, but I seemed to get a cold breeze whenever I needed one.

In case anyone is wondering, the hotel I stayed at is the Hampton Inn.  If you’re planning to do this race, you should be aware that this hotel has pros and cons.  On the plus side, you can’t beat the location for race day logistics.  It’s about half a block from the back of the start corrals and only three blocks from the starting line.  It’s also only about a block and a half from the finish area.

The big negative of this hotel is also the location.  It’s in a nightlife district, and there’s a place next to the hotel that plays loud music until at least 2 AM.  I was fortunate.  I had a room on the side of the hotel that’s farthest from the noise.  I occasionally heard a loud truck or motorcycle, but I didn’t hear the music.  I talked to runners with rooms on the other side of the building, and they were kept awake by the noise.  To their credit, the hotel staff provides earplugs to all their guests.


Race statistics:
Distance:  26.2 miles
Time:  3:45:50
Average Pace:  8:37 per mile
First Half:  1:50:59
Second Half:  1:54:51
Lifetime Marathons/Ultras:  532
Boston Qualifiers:  173
Place in Age Group:  3rd

No comments:

Post a Comment